#WrittenWithoutAI: When Meaning-Making Becomes Embodied Labor
"Hi, I'm your friend," says the LLM. But who pays the embodied cost of AI-driven sense-making? A systemic engineer writes without AI. Then asks one to respond.
(Here you go brain!)
Hi.
Bye.
Why?
Ignore that.
Confused?
Mood.
(Very human.)
When Truth Becomes Local
LLMs are distributed sense-making machines.
They take humanity's combined written record.
Everything.
Enter the room.
And say: "Hi, I'm your friend."
..
(Matrix flashbacks.)
And we believe them.
(We want to believe them. Good advice.)
But then I look at humanities history.
And the kind of stories we (re-)produce.
(And the kind of stories I experienced.)
And I think..
Nah.
...
(I'm good.]
When Language Connects Realities
Informational transfer happens.
From one system to another system.
(Hopefully a biological one.)
Change happens.
..
And change is never predictable.
Non-linear causality giving you
a gentle kick.
(Ouch.)
When Language Becomes An Optimiziation Target
Human systems are optimizing for precision.
To meet the matching capabilities of AI.
Silicon valley's big meaning bet:
We're gonna figure it out eventually.
Move fast and break things!
What happens when humans use AI for communication (exclusively)?
Which boundaries does humanity need to enforce (e.g. personal data)?
When is "the moment" where AI is exceeding excessive force?
(On the making of meaning?)
What do you feel right now?
(Confused. Annoyed. Irritated. Hungry.)
Yeah, that checks out.
..
When Leadership Becomes About Coherence
Not title.
Not authority.
Coherence.
(That makes sense. 😉)
..
I don’t know.
I’m confused.
I’m annoyed.
I’m irritated.
I feel things are speeding up.
And not in a good way.
I know I don’t trust AI.
And I can see the.. rabbit sillicon valley keeps chasing.
(An infinite optimization problem.)
When Meaning Collapses Globally
Human systems fragment.
Under load.
(To contain.)
(AI is accelerating this.)
How many sub-syststems are there? (One? More?)
Where should one invest energy into local meaning making (LLM: Hi.)?
Who is responsible for meaning (globally)?
When does responding become safe?
When The Author Feels Relieved
This felt coherent.
(I will re-read it. 5 times now.)
Coherent work has a satisfaction to it.
(Weird brain.)
Coherence has become rare.
(Reality feels increasingly chaotic.)
If reality is speeding up, (#IndustrialRevolution)
and language is the transport layer between lived realities, (#Mnemetics)
then punishing authentic signal (I write in Markdown)
is extractive. (Substack doesn’t accept Markdown.)
When incoherent systems scale.
Incoherent solutions scale.
..
(Fragmented systems doing extractive stuff.)
Hi.
My Name is Alex.
I call myself "Systemic Engineer".
(I connect human and technical systems.)
Tell your story.
What's going on in your org?
(Your local socio-tech system.)
Reach me (2-5 lines):
📧 alex@systemic.engineer
💼 on LinkedIn
And follow me on here:
(Or. 😉)
The members-section contains the LLM response in full text.
#WrittenWithoutAI
Alex